A few months ago I started reading a book called "You Can't Make Me, But I Can Be Persuaded" by Cynthia Ulrich Tobias. Unfortunately I sometimes trail off easily when it comes to non-fiction, but I was recently re-motivated in my reading of it and I finished the book last night.
I originally picked up this book because I had read James Dobson's "The Strong-Willed Child" and had seen little miss exhibiting some SWC behaviors. Little miss had me at my wits end with constant power struggles and I was seeking further guidance as to how I might direct her strong will without breaking it.
I have always lovingly and teasingly blamed my husband for our daughter's strong will. I once asked my mother-in-law if hubby was a SWC and she laughed out loud and exclaimed "Is the Pope Catholic?" Where in direct contrast to that, I never really gave my parents any trouble or argued with them, even during tumultuous teenage years. My mother has said that I was her easiest child to raise. She said I even potty-trained myself, that sounds like sainthood to me.
Since reading this book however, I realized there are a lot of behaviors I've exhibited throughout my life that are classic SWC behaviors. On a scale from 1 to 10 I am probably a 5 or 6. My parents, specifically my mother, were perfect to handle a SWC like myself. Never demanding of unquestioned, unwavering or unreasonable obedience. There was always a reason behind what I was asked to do and I knew it. They exercised parental authority, taught me things and disciplined me when the rare occasion called for it, but I always felt equipped to make decisions and exercise my agency.
When it came to other adults, like teachers and other leaders I was equally pleasant and compliant when they respected me and my agency. But nothing infuriated me more than rules with no reasons behind them, or authority figures who demanded complete obedience just because they were in charge.
There was one time I walked into a new classroom for the first time and a girl standing behind a video camera exclaimed "Stop! Now stand of that mark." I asked why and she just said impatiently "Just stand on that mark." I said no and walked to a seat. She issued me a command and I do not respond well to commands especially when they are issued with no explanation. She annoyingly turned to the teacher and said something like "Mr. So and so, she won't stand on the mark." He looked at me and thankfully said "let it be". The same teacher also had a very strict, unforgiving policy on tardiness. I remember I used to make it a point to be late. If I ever got there on time, I would wait outside the classroom until the bell rang and then walk in.
Another example of my strong-willed tendencies occurred at a girls camp I used to attend every summer. There was a lake at this camp that we went canoing in. Each year they overly stressed the fact that we were not allowed to swim in the lake and that tipping over the canoes was a very serious transgression. If we tipped over our canoes(which I never would have even thought about doing had they not suggested it and made such a big deal out of it), we would not be allowed on the lake the rest of the week and we would have to scrub every canoe with a toothbrush. The only reason they ever gave for why we were not allowed to tip the canoe or swim was a rumor that there were leeches in the lake. So here I was, presented with a rule that normally wouldn't have been a big deal if they had A) given me a logical reason behind it even if it was some stupid legality and B) not made such a big deal out of it in the first place. However, because they made such a huge deal out of it and denied me logical reasoning, every year I had to strongly fight the urge to tip over the canoe.
One year I decided I was going to tip over my canoe and I found a friend who agreed to do it with me. I thought about the action I was going to take and the consequences involved. If I tipped the canoe, I might possibly get a leech on me and I would have to scrub down all the canoes. I decided these consequences were completely acceptable for an opportunity to exercise my agency. So we tipped over the canoe. Well, really, I tipped over the canoe. My friend chickened out at the last minute and tried to steady the boat, but I insisted. Woo hoo, big deal, I tipped a canoe over. I got no leeches on me and we scrubbed down all the canoes.
One might say that I was just being a rebellious teenager, but I still see examples of my strong-willed nature even now. A few months ago I was with hubby in the kitchen. I can't remember the exact details, but I think I had a cup of water and was pretending to dump it on the floor. Then he made the mistake of saying something like "Don't you Dare!" Well of course I wasn't going to, but then he unintentionally issued the command/challenge. After he said that I couldn't help myself, I held his gaze and slowly poured the water out onto the floor. His initially astonished face broke into howling laughter as he said "I can't believe you did that! Why would you do that?" I grabbed a rag and soaked up the water while I laughed at myself. Why did I do things like that?
A few weeks ago I was talking to someone very dear to me. I won't get into the details, but during the course of the conversation they said "Don't you dare____" and "Promise me you will never ____". The thing we were talking about is something I NEVER intended of even thinking about doing, but just because of those statements, I had a really hard time responding. I had to force myself to say something like "Don't worry" through gritted teeth, when all I really wanted to do is yell, "And what if I did? Huh? HUH?"
I know that after reading some of the above examples, it might be easy to think I'm just a stubborn, rebellious, brat who is inclined to make rash decisions, but it is really not so. One of the things I found that I could relate to the most is that SWC don't expect to escape consequences. They consider them carefully and in fact will lose respect for those who don't enforce the consequences. I have never committed a brazen act solely to exercise my agency without first deciding whether or not I found the exchange worthwhile.
Another section of the book I found extremely interesting is where they address SWC and religion. It intrigued me because honestly, if someone is obsessed with not being told what to do, it seems like they would be completely incompatible for a relationship with a God who give commandments. Yet, I am religious. Part of me was wondering if those who are a strong-willed 10 at the far end of the scale, were just unable to have a religious element in their lives. But the more I thought about it and the more I read I realized that God is the greatest respecter of agency ever.
Duh. Which is really all an SWC really wants, respect for their agency to do whatever they want and a knowledge that they will be loved despite their seemingly thoughtless and bold actions.
I also found the book's discussion on what motivates SWC's to be religious particularly interesting because in a way it applies to all my relationships, religious or not. It said the primary motivator was the opportunity for a relationship with god and what that offers, not the punishment that can be avoided or the glory that can be received. I have always felt this way even to the point where I am sometimes uncomfortable discussing the promised blessings for certain actions. I do what I do for the sake of my relationship with god and the intensity with which I value that. If I had ever been taught or actually believed that there was a point where god wouldn't love me anymore, I would immediately not want a relationship with him. The relationship would have lost all value and meaning and the resentment might even carry me to be anti-religious. I would rather spend and eternity in hell than take part in a conditional relationship like that with a supreme being. Conditional relationships are just another way of exercising control over someone. Thankfully that is not the way it is. I don't really want to go to hell.
I am going to end this incredibly long post, but if anyone reading this suspects that they or someone they are close to is a SWC, I highly recommend this book.
Speaking of which, I have been meaning to issue a general invitation to join me on a new site called
GoodReads. It's a fun book site where you can compare, review and keep track of the books you read. I've been having enjoying it. If your interested, let me know and I'll send you an invite or let you know how to find me.