I've had several people express their distaste of the holidays to me lately. Their complaints are complaints I have heard before. It all comes down to one basic claim; "Christmas is Fake".
Some of these complaints focus around a perceived Scrooge Effect. It makes them sick to see people who are jerks most of the year, suddenly become angelic because it's Christmas. My first response is that whoever makes this argument watches too many movies. I have never seen the Scrooge Effect happen anywhere but in Christmas stories and folklore.
Even if the Scrooge Effect was a real and regular occurrence, they must be assuming that the person is insincere because I fail to comprehend the sickness that accompanies observing an event that prompts someone to get in touch with their humanity and become more Christ-like. I imagine it would be a beautiful thing to witness. If the person was insincere, something so drastic wouldn't be happening in the first place.
Another angle to the "Christmas is Fake" argument is that it is too commercialized. Well of course it is. Everything is commercialized these days. Just don't get caught up in it. Just because there are some people who have lost sight of what Christmas is about doesn't mean that everyone else has. And even if everyone else has, it doesn't mean you have to. That would be my response for the other similar argument that Christmas has lost it's meaning.
I'm sure there are many legitimate reasons why some people dislike Christmas, but when people talk about disliking Christmas because it's "so Fake", i just don't buy it. In my opinion, it's only fake if you allow it to be or make it that way.